Cut-Off Controls Where Goods Actually Move
Cut-off errors around goods are the easiest to make and the hardest to find two months later.
Read the next two paragraphs before the rest, because a good share of the companies this site is written for should stop after them.
If nothing physical crosses your threshold, none of this applies to you. A consulting firm, a software company, an agency, a professional practice: your cut-off risk is entirely about when work was performed and when an invoice was received, and those are different problems handled elsewhere. Skip to the last section, which is short and is written for you.
If anything physical does cross your threshold, this applies whether or not you think of yourself as a company that holds inventory. A field service business that stocks parts on its vans has goods cut-off. A manufacturer’s rep holding demonstration units has it. A clinic with consumables, a trades contractor with materials staged for a job, a distributor, a company that ships anything at all to a customer. The test is not whether you carry an inventory balance. The test is whether goods move across a boundary in the last few days of the period and the first few days of the next one.
The claim
Goods cut-off is controlled at the door, not in the ledger. A cut-off error is created at the moment a pallet is unloaded and the paperwork goes into a tray until Monday. Everything you do afterwards in the accounting system is reconstruction, and reconstruction of a physical event is genuinely hard: the paperwork does not carry the time it arrived, the driver has gone, and the only person who knows is the one who signed for it and has had a weekend since.
Which is why the cheapest evidence available is also the least used. Write down the last document number in every sequence at the moment the period closes. Ten minutes of somebody’s time on the last working day, and it converts a question that is nearly unanswerable at year end into one that takes five minutes.
The last working day: the number capture sheet
One sheet, one page, filled in at the end of the last working day of the period by the person who runs the door rather than by finance. Finance can chase it. Finance should not fill it in, because finance was not there.
| Sequence | What to record | Why it is on the sheet |
|---|---|---|
| Receiving report or goods received note | The last number issued | The line between goods that belong to this period and goods that do not |
| Supplier packing slips accepted | The last one accepted, and the supplier | Some suppliers send goods with no receiving document of your own attached to them |
| Shipping document, waybill or bill of lading | The last one issued | The equivalent line on the outbound side |
| Customer sales orders shipped | The last order marked shipped in the system | Catches the order marked shipped in advance so the warehouse could pick it |
| Purchase orders receipted | The last one receipted, plus a list of any receipted today | The most common place a receipt is entered on the wrong day |
| Work orders or jobs completed | The last one closed | Where the company manufactures or assembles |
| Inter-location transfers | The last transfer document, in both directions | Goods in a van overnight belong somewhere and are frequently claimed by both ends or by neither |
| Returns to suppliers | The last return authorisation issued | Goods physically gone and still on your books |
| Customer returns accepted | The last one accepted | Goods physically back and not yet credited |
Then three signatures on the bottom: who filled it in, the time, and the date. The time matters more than it looks, because the argument three weeks later is always about whether something arrived before or after the person left.
Keep the sheet with the close binder rather than in the warehouse. A capture sheet stored where the goods are is a capture sheet nobody in finance ever sees.
The physical hold
Numbers alone are not enough for the two areas where paperwork most reliably lags the goods. Those two get a physical control, and it takes tape and a printed sign.
Goods received and not yet processed. Everything unloaded in the last days of the period that has not been entered. Move it to a marked area, or tape off a corner of the receiving bay, and do not let anything leave that area until it has been entered with the correct date. The whole point is that the pile is visible. A pile you can see is a pile somebody counts on the first morning of the new period.
Goods picked and not yet shipped. The mirror problem, and the more expensive one, because a picked order looks shipped to everyone who walks past it. Segregate it, mark it, and record what is in it on the capture sheet as a list rather than as a number. These are the items most likely to be invoiced in the wrong period, and revenue landing in the wrong month is a larger problem than a cost doing the same.
The two areas should be empty within the first day or two of the new period. If either one still holds goods at the end of the first week, the issue is not cut-off, it is that receiving or shipping paperwork routinely runs several days behind the goods, and no period end procedure will fix that. Fix the daily process first and come back to this.
The morning after
First thing on the first working day of the new period, before anybody starts processing the new month’s transactions.
- Walk the two marked areas with the capture sheet in hand. Confirm what is physically there matches what the sheet says was there.
- Pull every transaction in the sequences on the sheet with a number above the recorded last number and confirm every one is dated in the new period. Anything above the line and dated in the old period is an error, and it is an error you can now see.
- Pull every transaction dated in the old period with a number below the line and confirm it is where it should be. This direction catches less, and it catches the one that matters most, which is a document raised out of sequence.
- Reconcile the receipts not yet invoiced. Everything receipted before the line with no supplier invoice against it is an accrual. This list is the direct input to the search for unrecorded liabilities, and it is usually the largest single item in it.
- Reconcile the shipments not yet invoiced. Everything shipped before the line with no customer invoice raised is either revenue you have not recorded or a shipment that should not have gone out. Both are worth knowing before the ledger closes.
- Deal with anything in transit. Below.
- Sign the sheet off and file it with the period’s reconciliations, in the same place as the bank reconciliation and the aged listings.
Steps 4 and 5 are the ones that convert this from a control into a number. Everything before them is evidence gathering. Those two produce journal entries, and they produce them on the first morning rather than on day six when the close is already under pressure.
Where a perfect door still gets it wrong
Four situations where the goods and the ownership part company, and the door tells you nothing.
| Situation | The question that decides it | What to do at period end |
|---|---|---|
| Goods in transit from a supplier | The shipping terms in the purchase contract, which say at what point title and risk pass | List every shipment despatched by the supplier before the period end that has not arrived, and apply the terms. Do not assume the terms are the same for every supplier. |
| Goods in transit to a customer | The same question on the outbound side, from your own sales terms | List them, apply the terms, and be consistent from period to period. A company that changes its answer between quarters has a bigger problem than the cut-off. |
| Drop shipments | Goods that never touch your door at all, shipped by your supplier directly to your customer | Neither sequence on the capture sheet will see these. Run them off the sales order and the supplier confirmation instead, and treat them as a separate list. |
| Goods held at a third party warehouse, or on consignment either way | Whose balance sheet the goods sit on, which is a matter of who holds the risks and rewards rather than who holds the pallet | Get a statement of holdings from the third party dated at the period end, and reconcile it. Ask for it in advance, because it will not arrive on its own. |
Drop shipments are the one that surprises people. A company can run an immaculate door and still have a whole revenue stream that the door never sees.
Counting, briefly, because it is a different question
How often a company counts, and whether it counts everything at once or cycles through, is a business decision that depends on value, mix, shrinkage history and how much the count costs to run. There is no universal answer and this piece will not offer one.
What is worth saying is the connection to cut-off, which is that a count is only as good as the cut-off around it. Counting on a day when goods are still moving produces a number nobody can reconcile, and the usual repair, adjusting for what moved during the count, reintroduces exactly the estimation the count was supposed to remove. If the company is going to count, freeze movement for the duration, or count in an area that is closed while the rest keeps working, and record the same document numbers at the start and the end of the count that this piece records at period end. The capture sheet works for both.
For the service company that read this far
If nothing physical moves, you have one thing to take from all of it, and it is the principle rather than the procedure: your cut-off line is a document sequence too.
The last timesheet entry, the last approved expense claim, the last job marked complete, the last purchase authorisation issued. Write down where each sequence stood at the period end, and on the first morning check the transactions on either side of the line. It is the same control, it takes five minutes rather than ten, and it belongs on the same page of the controls file as the version for companies that move goods.
What we do not do
We do not attend counts, test them or express any form of assurance on them. That is a different kind of work performed by a different kind of practitioner, and where a company needs it, we say so and get out of the way.
We do not tell a company how often to count, because the honest answer depends on facts about its own inventory that it knows and we do not.
And we do not accept a cut-off procedure that finance performs alone. The sheet is filled in by the person at the door, because the whole value of it is that it was written by somebody who was standing there.